Yay or nay? Accept this trade?

[seanm0520]

Get:

Tony Romo
Chris Johnson
Steve Breaston

Give:

Peyton Manning
Steve Slaton
Santonio Holmes

No PPR. Eli is my back-up. Pretty thin at RB no matter who have but without the catching bonus, Johnson is much better than Slaton and will continue to outscore him at a filthy pace this season. Is Peyton and Santonio to much to give up just for that upgrade? I'm thinking so but I'm not sure on not accepting simply because Eli is a legitimate fantasy starter this season. Breaston still gets his looks.

Thoughts?

Other RBs: Kevin Smith, Jamal Lewis, Maurice Morris (extremely thin, I know)
Other WRs: Santana Moss, Kevin Walter, Chansi Stuckey, Mark Clayton

 

[FairWarning]

I probably don't make the trade for the reason you gave. I like Holmes as a top-15 WR over what Breaston gives you. Your WR's would be weakened considerably. Take the WR's out of the mix, make it a 2-for-2, then I would do it.

 

[eaglezzz]

No way I make this trade. Manning is looking like he will be the top fantasy QB by the end of the year. Also Holmes is better then Breaston and Slaton got off to a slow start but he should start to get going